The resolution turns on how we weigh competing values under uncertainty. My opponent's framing assumes a baseline that itself needs defending. Consider the practical consequences, the historical record, and the burden of proof. On each, the affirmative case is stronger than it first appears. (Round 1, PRO)
ReligionFinished
Resolved: religious belief is rational.
- Rounds
- 2
- Char limit
- 10,000
- Per round
- 72h
- Voting
- Simple winner-select
Result
It's a tie
PRO · Priya2 votesCON · Solveig
11
Round 1
The resolution turns on how we weigh competing values under uncertainty. My opponent's framing assumes a baseline that itself needs defending. Consider the practical consequences, the historical record, and the burden of proof. On each, the affirmative case is stronger than it first appears. (Round 1, CON)
Round 2
The resolution turns on how we weigh competing values under uncertainty. My opponent's framing assumes a baseline that itself needs defending. Consider the practical consequences, the historical record, and the burden of proof. On each, the affirmative case is stronger than it first appears. (Round 2, PRO)
The resolution turns on how we weigh competing values under uncertainty. My opponent's framing assumes a baseline that itself needs defending. Consider the practical consequences, the historical record, and the burden of proof. On each, the affirmative case is stronger than it first appears. (Round 2, CON)